Sausalito Houseboats
By Larry Clinton | October 16, 2008
Long term Sausalitans remember the legend of the notorious humming toadfish, which stirred up quite a ruckus in Richardson’s Bay nearly three decades ago. Back in July and August of 1981, some houseboaters first began noticing reverberations through the hulls of their floating homes from sundown to sunup. The volume ranged from the sound of an electric shaver up to the level of an airplane engine at full throttle. When the noise returned in 1984, the dusk-to-dawn drone became intolerable at higher volumes, especially to those with bedrooms at or below the water line in steel-reinforced concrete hulls. Other forms of flotation do not seem to pick up on the toadfish “vibe.”
Theories as to the cause of the problem ranged from government navigational aids to diesel generators, sound “leakage” from an electric cable, emanations from a nearby sewage plant, or even extraterrestrials on summer vacation!
Responding to dozens of complaints, Waldo Point Harbormaster Ted Rose badgered various government agencies for help, only to be shunted from the Army Corps of Engineers to the Environmental Protection Agency to OSHA and on to PG&E. Some bedeviled residents funded private acoustic mapping and analyses of the harbor. Eventually these studies eliminated the possibility of mechanical sources, so biologists from Steinhart Aquarium were contacted to determine if the source could be biological. The search was finally narrowed to the humming toadfish (Porichthys notatus) aka Plainfin Midshipman (so called because the bioluminescent buttons on its ventral surface resemble those on a naval cadet’s jacket). John McCosker of Steinhart Aquarium trawled sonic “hot spots” in the mudflats, where the nightly humming had been recorded at 2-3 decibels above ambient noise. When lovesick and highly vocal individuals were caught at these precise locations, their sound signatures were compared with sounds recorded from within floating homes; they were identical, and the true culprits were unearthed (unmudded?). Those who found the hum intolerable were advised to move their beds upstairs, wear earplugs, or try a few nips of scotch before retiring. With so many environmental protections in place, there seemed to be no other recourse. As John McCosker put it, “You can’t sue a fish.”
Male toadfish ordinarily live at depths to 300 meters along the Pacific coast from Baja to Puget Sound, and enter bays and return to the shallows near the Golden Gate each year to breed. Once they find a suitable nesting spot, these eager bachelors summon likely mates by vibrating their gas bladders up to 150 times a second. The phenomenon has been documented as far back as the 1800s, so it must work.
The Sausalito toadfish story created a virtual media shower in the mid-80s. Local papers had been reporting on the mystery for months, andCBS Evening News sent a crew along on one of McCosker’s trawling expeditions. Several other national TV news shows picked up on this classic “only in Marin” story.
Although the mystery was solved, no solution to the problem has yet been devised. McCosker even tried disrupting the cacophonous courtship by dropping M-80 fireworks into the Bay. As he told Discover Magazine, “All that happened were some dull thuds, a few flashes of light, and the continuing hum of toadfish.”
In a classic case of making lemonade from lemons, floating homes residents created a Humming Toadfish Festival, which drew hundreds of curiosity-seekers to Sausalito’s Bay Model. John McCosker served as Grand Marshall the first year, and Phil Frank devised the festival’s humming toadfish logo. Lappert’s ice cream parlor even developed a toadfish flavored confection to sell at the site (it’s no longer on their menu). The festival was discontinued in 1990 when the fish took their act on the road, so to speak. They have returned to the floating homes community only sporadically ever since. However, the floating homes community’s Humming Toadfish Marching Kazoo Band pays tribute to the amorous critters in each Fourth of July parade.
Last summer, there were no reports of intrusive thrumming among the floating homes. John McCosker theorizes that abnormally low rainfall last winter affected toadfish-preferred salinity levels. Although he hasn’t been studying the toadfish lately, he suggests that fewer than usual may have visited Richardson’s Bay this year, or they may have clustered elsewhere for their mating rituals.
Wherever they set up housekeeping last summer, you can bet the toadfish baritones were humming their hearts out, because these hand-sized critters, which look like the black sheep of the catfish family, clearly need all the help they can get in the dating game.